If you can’t get to Sicily any time soon, bring Sicily home to you with some of my top ten must try authentic Sicilian recipes!
Unfortunately we won’t be able to get to Sicily as planned this summer as may be the case for many of you as well. So I decided to round up some of my favorite Sicilian dishes that I invite you to enjoy in the comfort of your own home!
Without a doubt, there are far more than ten amazing Sicilian dishes to try therefore by no means is this list exhaustive. So how did I choose which dishes made the cut for this list?
Each of these recipes has special meaning or memory linked to them. Some are favorites that I have been enjoying all my life made by my mother. Others are new discoveries that I had the opportunity to sample during recent trips to Sicily and inspired me to replicate them at home.
Influences on Sicilian cuisine
Sicily has been invaded by several civilizations over the last 2000 years resulting in a rich and diverse history. Each of these cultures has left their mark on Sicilian cuisine.
These include the Spanish, Greek, Normans, Romans and Arabs. In my opinion, most notable is the Arabic influence introducing ingredients such as citrus, saffron, raisins, and pine nuts as well as the combination of sweet and sour flavors.
So let’s begin my list with the recipe that is, without a doubt, one of the most popular Sicilian exports ever!
Top Ten Must Try Authentic Sicilian Recipes
Sicilian Cannoli with Ricotta Filling
Without a doubt Sicily's most iconic dessert known all over the world are cannoli! Of course, you can choose between a custard cream or ricotta filling but I'll choose ricotta each time. This is my mother's recipe which I have enjoyed all my life. Making your own cannoli is more time consuming than most desserts. But trust me when I say they are well worth the effort!
The Best Sicilian Arancini
Nowadays you'll find endless variations of arancini fillings in Sicily ranging from prosciutto to fish and seafood. However, in my opinion, the classic ragu with peas filled arancini remain my all time favorite. Just like my mom always makes!
Sicilian Brioche
Freshly baked brioche with granita are enjoyed all over Sicily for breakfast, for mid-morning snack time or even a late night snack. It is not uncommon to enjoy more than one per day! Other than stuffing them with gelato, the classic pairing for brioche is granita. I love traditional lemon granita however a second favorite would be this blueberry granita, a must try!
Panelle (Sicilian Chickpea Fritters)
Delicious crisp panelle or chickpea fritters are a typical street food in Sicily. And they're even better when served in a panino (bread roll), especially a sesame seed topped panini and drizzled with lemon juice. I enjoyed this delicious sandwich sitting on a picture perfect beach at Riserva dello Zingaro. Check out that photo here!
Sfincione Siciliano (Sicilian Style Pizza)
This Sicilian style pizza is in fact not referred to as a pizza at all in Sicily. Sfincione has a thick crust and is topped with a tomato sauce with lots of onions, crisp breadcrumbs and grated caciocavallo cheese. And, if you enjoy them, anchovies as well!
Eggplant Caponata
There's no doubt that the humble eggplant is the star of many Sicilian dishes including Pasta alla Norma and Eggplant Parmigiana. Caponata is unique in that it combines sweet and sour flavors for a unique dish which is delicious served hot or cold and can be an entire meal on it's own!
Homemade Busiate Pasta with Pesto alla Trapanese
In the province of Trapani busiate with pesto alla Trapanese rules supreme. This beautiful telephone cord shaped pasta is made with only 2 ingredients, semolina flour and water, and is almost always topped with a flavorful pesto made with cherry tomatoes, almonds, garlic and basil. The perfect summer pasta dish!
Eggplant Involtini with Maccaruna
Not many are familiar with this amazing dish which originates in my parent's part of Sicily in the province of Messina. This is served in most restaurants in the area as well as for special occasions. Eggplant slices are wrapped around homemade maccaruna pasta with tomato sauce and plenty of ricotta salata for the perfect main dish. Not to be missed!
Sicilian Pignolata
Pignolata also known as struffoli, cicerchiate or turdilli in different regions of Italy have always been part of our Christmas dessert table when my aunt was living. However, in Sicily, I had the pleasure of enjoying them on numerous occasions other than the Christmas holidays. And why not, after all why should these tasty little morsels drenched in honey be reserved for only one day throughout the year?
Sicilian Rosticceria Small Bites
And last but not least on my list: rosticceria foods! Although these are not considered as a meal in themselves, I was taken with these small bites that are found in bars and cafés all over the island. You'll also find them in rest area cafeterias. Our typical North American fast food rest area restaurants can't hold a candle to these delicious rollo with wurstel, mini pizzas or calzones! These are the perfect party finger foods or quick lunch in my opinion!
So there you have it, my ten must try authentic Sicilian recipes! You don’t have to travel to Sicily this summer to enjoy some of your classic favorites or discover new ones, all from the comfort of your own home!
Click here for my complete list of Sicilian recipes!
Let me know if you try any of these recipes. I’d also like to hear from you, so please let me know what your favorite Sicilian dish is in the comments below. Buon appetito!
Frank Fariello
I’m happy to say I’ve tried them all—well, almost. I missed out on trying rosticceria, although we passed by a small shop in Palermo. Alas, I had just had an enormous lunch and couldn’t eat another bite… Next time!
Nadia
Hi Frank, the rosticceria was impossible to pass up since we were travelling with out teenage children we had to stop frequently for a snack! Here’s hoping to a next time that’s real soon!
Anne Iacuzzo
Nadia —
I absolutely love this website … your recipes are wonderful. My beloved Nonna is no longer with me and her recipes were never written down — she had memorized the ingredients. I learned by watching,and sometimes helping her. Unfortunately, I am now 71 and have forgotten some of the ingredients for different recipes but you saved the day for me! Thank you for helping me preserve my Sicilian heritage. Grazie mille!
Nadia
Hello Anne, thank you very much, so kind of you! My mom’s recipes are written however they are not necessarily legible to me and don’t have precise instructions and so that’s why I set out to document them all in this blog. I want to be able to preserve them for future generations. I’m glad to hear I have been helpful to you, thanks again!
Nancy (salvo) Coppolino
I only make Sicilian style pizza . I love that it has a thicker body to it & not smothered with mozzarella. I usually use crushed tomatoes oregano Romano Cheese very thin sliced red peppers & thin sliced onions . My Aunt taught me how to make it & when it looks just right , once over LIGHTLY with Olive oil. Everyone raves over my pizza
Nadia
Hi Nancy, I agree with you, I also enjoy the thicker crust and not overly cheesy. Your pizza toppings sound delicious, must try! Thanks for your comment!